Mustard Collecting: A Unique Hobby to Spice Up Your Life

Collecting mustard might sound odd at first, but like the most of the unusual collectibles we highlight here on Collectorizing, it becomes much more interesting when you dive a little deeper into it.

From the charm of vintage mustard pots to the colourful tins and quirky bottles, mustard collecting can reveal a whole world of culinary history, art, and culture.

Types of Mustard Collectibles

Collecting mustard doesn’t mean just grabbing any old mustard jar. There are actually a few main categories to consider, each with its own appeal:

Mustard Pots

Mustard pots are probably the most traditional and visually interesting items. They’ve been around for centuries, with designs that reflect the styles of their times. You’ll find these made of porcelain, glass, stoneware, and even silver. Some of the oldest and rarest mustard pots have intricate details, hand-painted designs, and even tiny matching mustard spoons.

Mustard Tins

If you’re into vintage packaging, mustard tins will probably be your favorite. These colorful and often beautifully illustrated tins reflect a bygone era of advertising. Companies used tin cans to keep mustard fresh before the days of modern packaging. The artwork on some of these tins is stunning, featuring everything from floral designs to bold typography.

Mustard Bottles

Vintage mustard bottles add a different flavor to your collection. Older bottles were made from thick glass and sometimes had elaborate labels or embossing. You can find old-time favourites from popular brands or look for unique bottles that might have been used for special mustard varieties or by smaller, regional producers.

Types of Mustard People Like to Collect

Believe it or not, mustard comes in many forms, and collectors sometimes focus on collecting these different mustard varieties as much as they do the containers themselves. Here are some types of mustard you’ll find in a serious mustard collection:

Classic Yellow Mustard

You’re probably most familiar with this one. Classic yellow mustard is what you find on hot dogs and hamburgers everywhere. Even here, there’s variety—brands like French’s and Colman’s have their own takes on this traditional flavor.

Dijon Mustard

Dijon mustard has a smoother, creamier texture and a sharper flavor, which makes it a popular choice for gourmet recipes. Many collectors love the sleek bottles and labels that Dijon mustards come in, often from brands that originated in France.

Spicy Brown Mustard

This mustard has a coarser texture and packs a punch of flavor with its spiciness. It’s popular in the U.S., especially in places known for their sausages and meats. You’ll find brands like Gulden’s and Plochman’s producing spicy brown varieties.

Honey Mustard

Honey mustard combines sweetness with tang, making it a favorite for those who enjoy a milder mustard flavor. Its packaging often reflects this softer appeal, with pastel labels or honeycomb motifs.

Why Collect Mustard?

Why collect mustard, of all things? Well, for one, it’s a quirky and unique collectible. It’s a conversation starter and a way to celebrate a condiment that has been part of human culture for centuries. Collecting mustard containers, from tins to pots to bottles, provides a glimpse into the past—from the advertising strategies of old to the art styles that were popular in different eras.

Mustard also has historical significance. Did you know mustard has been used since ancient times? The Romans loved it, Shakespeare mentioned it in his plays, and French royalty couldn’t get enough of it. Collecting mustard is a way to connect with this rich history, and each item in your collection tells part of that story.

The National Mustard Museum in Middleton, Wisconsin

The ultimate place for any mustard collector is the National Mustard Museum in Middleton, Wisconsin. This museum holds over 6,000 varieties of mustard from all over the world, along with a fantastic selection of mustard-related items like antique pots, vintage advertisements, and mustard memorabilia. It’s the world’s largest collection of mustard, and it’s worth a trip if you’re ever in Wisconsin.

The museum was founded by Barry Levenson, who started collecting mustard in 1986 after a Red Sox loss that left him feeling pretty down. Wandering the aisles of a grocery store that night, he found himself in front of the mustard section and decided then and there to start collecting mustard. Today, his collection has become a global attraction, drawing mustard lovers from near and far. It’s full of history, humor, and of course, mustard tastings!

At the National Mustard Museum, you can try mustard samples, shop for unique mustards from around the world, and see an incredible variety of mustard pots, from classic silver to rare pottery pieces. This museum proves that there really is a whole world of mustard out there to explore.

check out the Youtube video below!

Where to Find Collectible Mustard

Now that you’re itching to start your own mustard collection, where can you find collectible mustard items? Here are a few great places to begin your search:

• Etsy – This is my personal favorite spot for finding unique mustard collectibles. There’s a wide variety of mustard pots, vintage tins, and old bottles from all over the world. You’ll often find sellers with truly special pieces, and it’s a good platform for discovering handmade or one-of-a-kind items. (Check the image below)
• National Mustard Museum Gift Shop – They have a gift shop where you can buy items right from the source. They carry a variety of mustards, plus museum souvenirs and books about mustard and mustard collecting.
• eBay – This is a classic for all collectors. You can find everything from mustard bottles and tins to rare mustard pots on eBay. Just make sure to check the seller’s reviews and inspect the photos closely.

How to Choose Mustard Items to Collect

When you’re starting out, don’t worry about finding rare pieces right away. Focus on finding items that interest you. Maybe you’ll want to collect mustard pots with floral designs, or perhaps you’re into old advertising tins. As you grow your collection, you’ll start to get a feel for the types of items you’re most passionate about.

Remember, you don’t have to spend a lot of money to start. Some collectible mustard pots or tins can be found for less than $20. Of course, there are also high-end pieces that might cost hundreds or even thousands of dollars, especially for rare antiques or items with historical significance.

How to Store and Care for Your Mustard Collection

Proper storage is essential for keeping your mustard collection in good condition. If you’re collecting mustard pots or bottles, make sure to store them in a cool, dry place. You might even consider using a display case to keep dust off of your items. For tins, avoid places with high humidity, as this can cause them to rust. Gently dust your items every so often, and for silver pieces, use a soft cloth to keep them shiny.

How to Connect with Other Mustard Collectors

Connecting with other collectors can make the hobby even more enjoyable. Currently, there’s only one mustard group worth recommending which opens up a great opportunity for yours truly. Why not start your own Facebook page today and be a mustard pioneer!

In the meantime, check out this Reddit group

• Reddit: r/mustard – The subreddit has a community of mustard lovers from all over. You’ll find everything from discussions about rare finds to advice on where to buy mustard pots.

Conclusion: The Joy of Collecting Mustard

Collecting mustard is a fun and quirky hobby that’s definitely off the beaten path. So if you’re looking for something unique to collect, this is certainly one of the more unique things to collect!

It offers a way to celebrate a condiment that’s been around for centuries, learn about different cultures, and connect with a community of fellow collectors.

Whether you’re into the beautiful designs of mustard pots or the nostalgia of vintage tins, you’ll find that mustard collecting can add a bit of spice to your life.

So if you’re looking for a hobby that’s a little different, why not start collecting mustard? With its blend of art, history, and culinary charm, it’s a collection that’s sure to grow on you.

Some of the links in this post are affiliate links, which means if you click through and make a purchase, I’ll earn a little something at no extra cost to you. It’s a cool way for you to find awesome stuff while supporting the blog. I promise I only shout out products and services that I genuinely love and think you will too!